Are You a Lipstick Hoarder? Don't Worry, Sarah Hyland Is Too

"I got married last year in Palm Springs around the same time as her birthday and a few family conflicts came up, so she couldn't make it," Avendaño said. "Her hairstylist Ryan Richmond [right] was there with his family, and he kept disappearing. Then all of a sudden he walks out with a life-size photo of Sarah waving to the crowd. It was from the Emmys, when she wore a big, coral Christian Siriano ballgown. She painted it white because she said if she did come to the wedding, she would come in a big white wedding dress just to be funny. So technically, she was there — and we were taking photos with her all night."

"In the beginning of her career, she looked so young," he said. "She might have been playing a teenager on Modern Family, but really she was an adult, so she always wanted to look a little older. We would always do smoky eyes or a more glamorous, sophisticated look. Everyone was always comparing her to Mila Kunis, so that's what we were going for. Sometimes, we'd get so carried away — we'd be like, 'Let's do black shadow and really smoke it out!' As she's gotten older, we've switched from black to a soft brown or purple eyeliner. We stick to neutral tones these days for a more natural look."

"When it comes to drugstore products, I tend to be particular about what I'll use on her just because I want it to last all night," he said. "Her skin is amazing, so she doesn't need to do much, but I will apply the Differin Oil-Control Moisturizer ($10) as a base just to hold up the makeup. If you put makeup on dry skin, it'll start to look chalky."

"Honey, I've used every lipstick on her from L'Oréal, Neutrogena, Revlon . . ." he said. "We use a lot of the Revlon Kiss Lip Pumping Creme ($4). It's not a lipstick or gloss, it just gives this sheer color that's really nice."

"We're always getting in mascaras and trying new ones, but L'Oréal [Voluminous Mascara ($8)] has always been a holy grail — we've been using it for years."

"Sarah is such a good friend of mine and she melts my heart, so really I'll give her anything she wants," Avendaño said. "I always use the Cetaphil Wipes ($9); they are so gentle and take everything off in one swipe. I've given her a whole packs of those wipes."