This $16 Eyebrow Pencil From Amazon Made Me Throw All My Others in the Trash

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

I spent my teenage years plucking off my already sparse eyebrows in the hopes it would turn me into Kate Moss. Now, I'm spending most of my 20s investing time and money into getting them back. From dyeing them to using growth serum, makeup pens, gels, and powders, my brows have seen it all. But recently, I came across a product that replaced almost everything in my overflowing drawer. I gave this P/Y/T Beauty Brow Pencil ($16) a try and haven't used another product since.

The consistency of the pencil is like a gel, pen, and powder all rolled into one.

The consistency of the pencil is like a gel, pen, and powder all rolled into one. It glides on my skin without looking overly done, and most importantly, it doesn't come off until I use makeup remover. This is the first time that filling in all those bald gaps actually looks natural. Another huge selling point for me is that the pencil is hypoallergenic and paraben-, paraffin-, and cruelty-free. So, what are you waiting for? Try it for yourself. It is available on Amazon Prime and will be delivered right to your door in just two days.

P/Y/T Beauty Brow Pencil
amazon.com

P/Y/T Beauty Brow Pencil

I have the P/Y/T Beauty Brow Pencil ($16) in taupe, but it comes in four other shades.

P/Y/T Beauty Brow Pencil
pytbeauty.com

P/Y/T Beauty Brow Pencil

You can see the consistency is like a pencil and gel mixed together.

Before and After
POPSUGAR Photography

Before and After

Here I have my left brow drawn in and my right brow bare.