Popsugar Beauty Maybelline New York Extreme Lashes at Met Gala 2019 These Extreme Eyelashes From the Met Gala Deserve a Closer Look May 7, 2019 by Kirbie Johnson View On One Page Photo 17 of 23 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 17 Madelaine Petsch At her debut at the Met Gala, Madelaine Petsch sported an ethereal pink shadow and what appeared to be naturally long, gorgeous lashes, with makeup by Alex Byrne. Previous Next Start Slideshow Lady GagaLizzoMaybelline New YorkPriyanka ChopraGigi HadidBeauty NewsDarren CrissMet GalaLily CollinsCelebrity Beauty