Every Product Used to Create Kate and Jeanette's '90s Beauty Looks in Cruel Summer

If Kate reminded you a bit of Rachel Green and Cher Horowitz blended together, that's the intention. "Her color palette is very pinks, which was also very popular in the '90s, so I kept everything really fresh and bright," Trujillo said. She used all MAC Cosmetics products in Kate's look because that's what "everybody chic used at the time."

But Kate wouldn't be complete without her bright blond blowout. "In '93, I wanted her to be the stereotypical American blond girl," Kirkpatrick said. He wanted to make her highlights look intentionally unnatural, that way you knew she frequented a hair salon. "It showed she paid attention to how she looked and tried to improve herself," he said.