14 Lip Liners Our Editors Swear By

ColourPop in BFF 3 ($7)

"My favorite lip liner has to be the ColourPop in BFF 3. It is the perfect brown that isn't too dark to where it entirely takes over a lip look but it also isn't too light where it doesn't show up. It is literally my perfect shade. I have backups for my backups, so I definitely don't plan on running out soon, but if I do, for $7, it doesn't hurt to grab a few extra." — Ariel Baker, associate editor, Beauty