If I Lost My Makeup Bag, These Are the Products I'd Repurchase Immediately

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner in Brown Denim ($11)

I will forever kick myself for all of the years I wasted not wearing eyeliner because I thought it was "too much effort." Please! Adding a little gel eyeliner to the upper and lower lash line, and the tiniest wing in the outer corner, is one of the most flattering things I've ever done for my makeup routine — and it's so easy to achieve. I love this eyeliner because the gel formula is blendable — at least before it dries down — and glides across the skin with ease. The formula is waterproof, transfer-proof, and can last up to 36 hours. Not even my oily eyelids can bring it down.