15 Makeup Gift Sets Recommended by Pros and Editors

Ilia Beauty Lip Sketch Trio ($34)

"I don't wear lipstick often, but when I do, I reach for the Lip Sketch Hydrating Crayon from Ilia Beauty. It's as precise as a lip liner and goes on smoothly like a creamy lipstick. The soft-matte formula is long-lasting (minimal touchups required!) and available in a variety of shades. I don't have a red crayon in my collection — but I have a feeling I'll be needing one for the holidays." — Alida Araica, newsletter manager