Every Single E.L.F. Beauty Product in the New "Mean Girls" Movie, Ranked

E.L.F. O Face Satin Lipstick ($9)

Spot it: Worn by Cady in class

I like lipsticks that don't make wearing them feel like a full-time job. Essentially something that glides on easily without the need for liner or a magnifying mirror and that won't jump ship the moment I take a sip from my water bottle. This is a real box ticker with a creamy, satin texture that's a doddle to swipe onto lips with impressive color payoff in just one coat. I did my usual apply, blot, reapply, and blot again, and that was enough to keep it in place for a good four hours before needing to touch up. It's available in 20 shades from neutral nudes to deep berry tones — and plenty of pinks for Wednesdays, obvs.