Overgrown or Overplucked? 21 Products From Sephora to Get Your Brows Back on Track

By picking up this limited-edition Anastasia Beverly Hills Better Together Brow Kit ($24), you get two of the brand's bestselling products packed together: a full-size Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz ($23) pencil — with more than 10,000 five-star reviews — helps to outline and fill brows, and a mini, clear Anastasia Beverly Hills Clear Brow Gel ($9-$22) sets the look all day long.

For something with color and hold, this top-rated KVD Vegan Beauty 24-Hour Super Brow Long-Wear Pomade ($10-$20) offers highly saturated hues ranging from "natural" hair shades to bold cherry red, emerald green, and electric blue, too. [This equally popular KVD Vegan Beauty #70 Pomade Brow Brush ($18) gets the job done, no matter the color you choose.]

All the colors of this popular Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel ($14-$38) feature tiny microfibers to boost volume while also taming and tinting brows at the same time.

This top-rated Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Mousse ($29) reduces oil around the hair follicle so skin is nourished and balanced, and then patchy spots are smoothly filled in with lightweight color.

This top-rated Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil ($34) creates full brows thanks to its special angled tip that draws on its powder, pencil, and wax blend as thin or thick as desired.

Each Milk Makeup Kush Fiber Brow Gel ($20) has hemp-derived cannabis seed oil inside (to condition and set brows), while its tapered brush lets the tinted, flake-free gel evenly spread throughout.

Pluck stray hairs with the popular Tweezerman Stainless Steel Slant Tweezer ($23) as the hand-filed tips can easily grab exactly what you want . . . and not what you don't.

These top-rated Anastasia Beverly Hills Scissors ($23) are just the right shape and length to trim down any stray brow hairs.

IT Cosmetics Brow Power Micro ($24) has a tiny oval tip that mimics the look of a microbladed brow by adding superfine, hair-like lines — and 97 percent of the Sephora shoppers who reviewed this product would recommend it to others for doing just that.

If you're looking to treat the root(s) of your patchy brows, this Grande Cosmetics GrandeBrow Brow Enhancing Serum ($36-$70) boasts vitamins, antioxidants, and amino acids to help your hair look fuller in spots where it's naturally thinning or a little overplucked.

The argan- and coconut-oil-packed Josie Maran The Good Brow ($24) not only shapes and fills brows (with the pigmented end), but it also offers a Rosé highlighter side to brighten the area right under your brows (and inner corners of your eyes), too.

Each Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Powder Duo ($23) compact comes with two colors so you can get a natural, buildable blend as needed — and it's earned a 4.7 rating from Sephora shoppers. (It's easy to apply with this dual-sided flat brush/spoolie Anastasia Beverly Hills Brush #7B ($18) that also earns top marks.)

Use this top-rated Sephora Collection Eyebrow Touch Up Razor Set ($15) to trim brows with a tiny blade — and the cap includes a bonus comb and brush to get things in order afterward as well.

With more than 3,000 five-star reviews, this waterproof Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape and Define ($14-$24) comes in 12 different shades so you can get a close color match to fill in sparse spots and then use the other end to blend it all in so brows look more defined (yet still natural).

This versatile Shiseido Kajal Ink Artist Shadow, Liner, Brow ($25) can add necessary color to fill in brows, but it also lines and shades lids because it's got a detachable sharpener and built-in sponge to get all that done.

A little goes a long way with this volumizing Charlotte Tilbury Legendary Brows Eyebrow Gel ($23), plus there's nourishing vitamin E and strengthening castor oil inside to treat hair well, too.

The top-rated Sephora Collection Retractable Brow Pencil ($12) can create hair-like, smudge-proof strokes, and comes in 10 different colors (all with a spoolie end to also shape and tame your natural brows).

Sure, this Viseart Eyeshadow and Eyebrow Palette ($64, originally $80) has nine matte eyeshadows inside, but there are also three different wax-based colors to fill in light, medium, and dark brows (or any shade in between).

The top-rated, retractable Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Ultra-Fine Precision Brow Pencil ($29) lets you fill in brows lightly or with a bolder effect — and there are six color choices, including a universal taupe shade, to work on a range of hair colors and skin tones.

The gel-like Make Up For Ever Aqua Brow ($23) comes in seven highly pigmented, natural shades to reshape and fill in brows with intense color that won't fade throughout the day.

The simple, self-sharpening Clinique Superfine Liner For Brows ($19) can fill in tiny gaps in your brows so you have a well-defined, even shape in the end.