Neil admitted that he was immediately taken with David when they were introduced by a mutual friend in 2004, but they didn't get together until after David and his boyfriend called it quits. "Once we started talking, we never stopped," Neil told Out magazine in 2012. "I initially fell for David harder than he fell for me. I was in love with him before he was comfortable saying it, and I think that speaks to our past experiences. I remember saying, ‘I think I love you,’ and he was like, ‘That’s really nice.’" David proposed to Neil in 2007 on the street corner where they first met, and Neil then proposed to David on Valentine's Day the following year. The couple are parents of twins Gideon and Harper and said "I do" in Perugia, Italy, in September 2014.
