Who Was Your First Celebrity Crush? 23 Women Reveal Who First Stole Their Heart

"I was REALLY into Noah back in the early years of ER. I know George Clooney was there too, but Dr. Carter was definitely my top crush. Of course, my little sister also decided she was in love with him, which led to many a dispute about who got ownership of the photos of him in Seventeen and YM (for cutting and plastering all over our bedrooms)." — Becky Kirsch, senior content director