Who Was Your First Celebrity Crush? 23 Women Reveal Who First Stole Their Heart

"JTT was the first boy I ever actively thought about on a daily basis. I couldn't get enough of him in Man of the House and I willingly destroyed a few friendships at my ninth birthday party by demanding I take home a poster of him during a game. And once he popped up in my dream (we were working at a car wash together), all bets were off." — Caitlin Hacker, celebrity editor