12 Celebrity Proposal Stories That Are Almost Too Over-the-Top to Be True

After falling in love during a margarita-fueled night at a club, Matthew McConaughey knew he wanted to marry Camila Alves. When he finally asked, though, he kept her in suspense. The Gold actor proposed on Christmas morning by hiding a rose-cut Cathy Waterman engagement ring at the bottom of a series of multiple boxes. When she finally got to the smallest box, it must've been a pretty lovely surprise.