All of Blake Lively's Former Flames Have 1 Thing in Common

Blake and Ryan sparked dating rumors when they were spotted grabbing ice cream together at Disneyland in October 2010. A couple months later, the NY Daily News reported that the duo was packing on the PDA at Ryan's Blue Valentine afterparty. "They've been out a few times and are definitely into each other, but I don't think it's super serious or anything right now," a friend of Ryan's told E! News at the time. "Yeah, they're casually dating, but I could see it becoming more." Those rumors shortly fizzled out after that.