Who Has Michelle Williams Dated? Look Back at Her Under-the-Radar Romances

Michelle and Jeremy first met on the set of Baywatch in 1993 and secretly dated for two years. "We messed around. She was, kind of like, my first crush, puppy dog love . . . (She was) my secret rendezvous girlfriend," the actor previously told Howard Stern. "I was learning the ropes, man. If you want to make an omelette, you've got to break some eggs, right?"