A month after (maybe) kissing Stephanie, Michael reportedly began romancing Caroline Pal, who at the time was working as a waitress at the Palms Casino Resort's Moon Nightclub. According to a source for People, the swimmer even took Caroline home to Maryland to meet his family for Thanksgiving after just about two months of dating. It's not clear how long the paired dated, but they did spark reconciliation rumors in March 2013 when they were reportedly spotted looking "very flirtatious" in Las Vegas. "They seemed to be having a lot of fun," a source claimed to Page Six at the time. Little else was heard about the maybe-couple after the rumored hangout.