Shay Mitchell Doesn't Want to Get Married but She'd "Love to Have a Commitment Ceremony" in 10 Years

Mitchell and Butler sparked romance rumors in May 2016 when they were spotted enjoying lunch together at Il Pastaio restaurant in Beverly Hills, per People. Their outing came months after the two were spotted chatting court-side at the Staples Center when Butler — who played for the Chicago Bulls at the time — was in town with his team to face off against the Los Angeles Lakers.

Adding fuel to the fire, Butler had previously spoken out about how Mitchell was his celebrity crush during a YouTube Q&A. "I'd probably go with Shay Mitchell, who plays Emily on 'Pretty Little Liars,'" Butler said at the time.

"She's really, really good-looking," he added. "Shay Mitchell it is."

Their romance was never officially confirmed.