Popsugar Celebrity Jake Johnson Jake Johnson and Erin Payne Relationship Timeline Inside Jake Johnson and Erin Payne's 20-Year Relationship September 5, 2023 by Michele Mendez View On One Page Photo 3 of 5 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 3 2014: Jake Johnson and Erin Payne Welcome Twin Daughters Johnson and Payne welcomed their twin daughters, Elizabeth and Olivia, in 2014. Ever since they were born, the couple have kept their children mostly out of the public eye. Previous Next Start Slideshow Jake JohnsonCelebrity CouplesCelebrity FactsRelationship Timeline