The Babysitter: Killer Queen Stars Discuss Their Character Arcs, Movie References, and That Twist
While 2017's The Babysitter became a cult classic with horror fans, its sequel The Babysitter: Killer Queen has rightfully earned a spot with beloved teen horror favorites, like Friday the 13th and A Nightmare on Elm Street. Judah Lewis stars as social outcast Cole who's still reeling from the events of The Babysitter, while Emily Alyn Lind plays his best friend/crush Melanie. Killer Queen follows what happens when Cole decides to forget the past and join Melanie at a lake for a party he'll never forget. When things finally start to go his way, the satanic cult resurfaces to finish the ritual they started all those years ago.
As Cole, Lewis isn't your typical "final girl" — primarily because he's a boy — making the title "final girl" seem far more suited for Lind's Melanie. However, about 30 minutes into the film — which is now streaming on Netflix — we quickly realize there's a reason Melanie won't be the "final girl:" she's the villain who betrays Cole like his babysitter Bee does in the first film. In a recent interview with POPSUGAR, Lewis and Lind discussed how their characters have changed between films, their reaction to the big twist, and director McG's excellent usage of movie references.
"Mine and Judah's character, Cole, go through an ordeal that brings us really close together."
In The Babysitter, we see what we hope are the seeds of a romantic relationship between Melanie and Cole. When Killer Queen picks up two years later, though, they're just friends. "Mine and Judah's character, Cole, go through an ordeal that brings us really close together, but then we both decided to deal with that differently," Lind explained about what happened to the pair between films. "Melanie sort of deals with it by pretending it never happened and trying to be normal, and Cole deals with that by feeling like he might be insane while wanting to find the truth because it affected him more."
Melanie is popular, while Cole (who is on a plethora of pills and visits the school's guidance counselor almost every morning) is an outcast. "I think for Cole, it's like a slow burn," Lewis mentioned, "There's this feeling of incredible joy that he's able to finally move on with his life. And then, suddenly, it all turns in on him when it turns out that all the evidence is gone and he can't prove any of this took place. Over the two years of people not believing him and him being medicated, he's really just trying to survive high school."
"It's such a gut punch, just like Bee's turn in the first movie was in a very similar way."
When we see Cole and Melanie together, we feel as if "they have this beautiful connection" and that Melanie is still looking out for him. That's why her reveal at the lake almost feels like the ultimate betrayal. On how Lind felt about becoming the villain, he said, "It was really fun being able to do the switch . . . [especially] the manipulation that she does to Cole in order to try and kill him." However, it wasn't as fun for Lewis. "I was devastated . . . I think for Cole, he finds himself in this world where Melanie is his only true friend. And in all of that, everybody thinks he literally lost his mind now, which in turn, is causing him to think he may have lost his own mind. It makes it all the more unbelievably devastating when that turn does happen. It's such a gut punch, just like Bee's turn in the first movie was in a very similar way."
Melanie's betrayal wasn't the only twist in Killer Queen. During the end credits scene of the first film, we see that Bee survives her injuries, and at the end of the sequel, we find that Bee is the titular "Killer Queen." But instead of killing Cole and Phoebe, she tampers with the ritual that ends with the deaths of Melanie and the blood cult — and not even Lewis saw that coming. "I think Cole and Bee's connection in the first film is so magical and so incredible," he said. "To be able to kind of resurrect that in such an incredibly beautiful way where she gets to redeem herself and we get to be on the same team again, was just such a fun surprise." For Lind, the twist shows how Melanie isn't as innocent as we are initially led to believe. "You never see it coming. [Melanie] totally is hiding behind this facade of wanting to be an Instagram celebrity, and she'd do anything to get to that point. Even betray her best friend."
How Bee convinces Melanie to betray Cole is just one of the many, many movie and pop culture references director McG snuck into the film. "That's from The Social Network when Justin Timberlake's talking to Jesse Eisenberg, [saying] 'A million dollars isn't cool. You know what's cool? A billion dollars,'" Lind replied, before mentioning that her other favorites were all the Terminator references, including her line, "Even Terminator says, 'I'll be back.'"
"You can sit down and watch it as this insane roller-coaster, horror comedy, but for attentive viewers there's also just tons of little Easter eggs that you can pick up on."
Unless you're an '80s movie fan or a Rob Reiner fan, you might not catch Lewis's favorite reference. In a callback to new girl Phoebe's entrance to the school, what starts out as a nod to Deliverance devolves into a monologue pulled from 1985's The Sure Thing, as Cole goes to save her from a creepy camper. "That's kind of what's so fun about this film," Lewis added. "It's just so full of homages and nods and little references to other films. You can sit down and watch it as this insane roller-coaster, horror comedy, but for attentive viewers, there's also just tons of little Easter eggs that you can pick up on." Even the film's final death scene is an homage to Game of Thrones. "We totally get poisoned and our eyes go all the way back, so it was really fun to shoot," Lind said with a laugh. You'll understand her laughter after seeing the film, because the way everyone dies is the perfect end to such a campy and fun film.