Elliot (Michael Showalter) is used to heartbreak. After all, The Baxter is the story of the nice guy whose girlfriends always seem to find a truer love than him. Though every girlfriend he's ever had has been wooed back by an ex, one can't help but feel bad when he's finally about to exchange vows and his bride's (Elizabeth Banks) long-lost high school love (Justin Theroux) busts in and steals her away! He does snag Michelle Williams at the end, so it's not all bad.