The Oscar Nominee Hall of Shame: Films They May Not Want You to Remember

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 20 percent

Jared Leto wasn't exactly resting on his laurels between My So-Called Life and Dallas Buyers Club, and in 1998, he appeared in the slasher movie Urban Legend as a college journalist. The movie have had an interesting premise but a sloppy execution (a dog in a microwave, ugh), but we can't fault Leto's performance. Look how cute he is here!