The Complicated, Interconnected History of The Bachelor Franchise

The Bachelor and Bachelorette franchises may have started out as random singles just looking for love the old-fashioned way, but after 20 seasons, it's become a much more complicated web of interconnectedness. For a time, certain Bachelors were chosen out of the blue for their appeal, but the franchise producers soon discovered that they could get a built-in audience by casting runners-up and fan favorites from previous seasons. But after this many years, it's easy to forget who was almost chosen by who, so we're breaking down which Bachelors and Bachelorettes landed their position of rose-giving by being an ousted contestant first. Starting from the very first bachelor, Alex, to the current bachelorette, JoJo, here's how each season has ultimately led to the next.


Alex Michel
Everett Collection

Alex Michel

It all started, lo those many years ago (2002 to be exact), with this unsuspecting fella. He entered the very first cocktail party to face 24 women and the rest is history. Alex had the dubious distinction of being the first Bachelor, and he set the standard for 20 seasons of romantic melodrama and competition.

Trista Rehn
Everett Collection

Trista Rehn

We may not remember Alex very well, but without his role as the world's first Bachelor, we would never have met Trista. Alex may not have picked her, but America certainly did, and she wound up being the first Bachelorette.

Trista fell in love with Ryan Sutter, world's most handsomely chill firefighter, and the two are still married to this day. In fact, they are the gold standard when it comes to dating-show romance.

Bob Guiney
Getty

Bob Guiney

We first met Bob on Trista's season, but he was third runner-up that go around. He was a fan favorite because of his class-clown nature and he wound up being the season four Bachelor.

He was charming and affable, and when it came down to the final two, he picked Estella Gardinier. The two broke up shortly thereafter, and he went on to marry and divorce soap-star Rebecca Budig.

Meredith Phillips
Getty | Chris Walter

Meredith Phillips

While Bob was busy proposing to Estella, Meredith, his third runner up, went on to be the second Bachelorette. She picked Ian McKee, but the two broke up less than a year later.

Jen Schefft
Getty | Alexander Tamargo

Jen Schefft

Before Bob and Meredith, there were Jen and Andrew. Jen appeared as a contestant on the third season of The Bachelor, on which tire-magnate Andrew Firestone was the suitor.

Andrew proposed to Jen, but it didn't get far, and the two broke up pretty publicly. Jen went on to star as the season three Bachelorette, and she didn't accept the proposals of either of the final two men — a shocking turn of events for the time.

Brad Womack
Everett Collection

Brad Womack

Season 11 was the first of Brad Womack's two turns as the Bachelor, but his first ended in disappointment all around. He didn't pick either girl and sent everybody home crying.

DeAnna Pappas
Everett Collection

DeAnna Pappas

DeAnna was a castoff from Brad's season, but since he didn't really pick anyone, the heartbreak was manageable. DeAnna went on to be the season four Bachelorette, and picked hunky snowboarder Jesse Csincsak over sweet, single dad Jason Mesnick.

Jason Mesnick
Getty | Denise Truscello

Jason Mesnick

The aforementioned sweet single dad Jason Mesnick parlayed his rejection into a shot at love in the thirteenth season of The Bachelor. Jason famously pulled an ol' switch-a-roo when he rejected Melissa Rycroft after proposing and then begged for a second chance from runner-up Molly Malaney.

Jillian Harris
Getty | Sonia Recchia

Jillian Harris

Jillian escaped Jason's indecision from the previous season, going on to be the Bachelorette in season five. Jillian was the first Canadian woman to star on the show.

Jake Pavelka
Getty | Paul Archuleta

Jake Pavelka

Jillian's season made the way for Jake to be the season 14 star. He became engaged to Vienna Girardi in the March finale, and the two announced their breakup in June of the same year. Jake went on to cultivate himself quite a career in the reality show genre. He made appearances on Dancing With the Stars, Bachelor Pad, Famous Food, and The CW's short-lived, H8R before returning briefly to this season of The Bachelorette.

Ali Fedotowsky
Getty | Emma McIntyre

Ali Fedotowsky

Ali appeared on Jake's season, but in a franchise first chose her career over the show and returned to her job at Facebook. Ali was a fan favorite, and as a result became the sixth Bachelorette. Ali got a fiancé, Roberto Martinez, out of the deal, but she also got quite a career, as well. After the show, she moved back to San Diego to be a morning correspondent on a Fox affiliate, then went on to host the show 1st Look, and then served as a special correspondent on the E! Network.

Brad Womack
Everett Collection

Brad Womack

Because once is never enough, Brad returned for his second turn on The Bachelor in season 15. The second time was a bit more fruitful, and he actually did propose to Emily Maynard, sending runner up Ashley Hebert packing. Thus not one but two Bachelorettes came out of Brad's season.

Ashley Hebert
Getty | Dimitrios Kambouris

Ashley Hebert

Ashley was cast off by Brad, but found her stride as the seventh Bachelorette. Ashley accepted JP Rosenbaum's proposal, and the couple are still married with one child and another on the way.

Ben Flajnik
Getty | Steven Lawton

Ben Flajnik

Ben may have been Ashley's second, but he was number one in fans' hearts. He went home heartbroken from Ashley's season, but he didn't stay that way for long. He became the Bachelor for season 16, in which he chose the controversial Courtney Robertson. The two broke up soon after.

Emily Maynard
Getty | Rebecca Sapp

Emily Maynard

Even though Brad proposed to Emily, it was a brief affair, and she went on to be the Bachelorette for season eight. Emily was beloved by audiences and she could do no wrong, even when she picked the questionable Jef Holm. That relationship didn't make it very far, and Emily went on to marry a man she met at church. She remains very popular among Bachelor fans, and has her own lifestyle brand — books, apps, and a website to prove it.

Sean Lowe
Getty | Jonathan Leibson

Sean Lowe

Even though Sean didn't get to propose to Emily, he's usually counted as one of the franchise's success stories. He proposed to Catherine Giudici and they were married in 2014. The couple will also welcome their first child later this year.

Desiree Hartsock
Getty | Robin Marchant

Desiree Hartsock

Desiree may have come in fourth in Sean's season, but she was beloved enough to be chosen for season nine of The Bachelorette. She chose Chris Siegfried and the two were married in 2015, and are now expecting a child.

Juan Pablo Galavis
Getty | Rodrigo Varela

Juan Pablo Galavis

Juan Pablo was one of the more polarizing bachelors, and not just from Desiree's season, either. He was outspoken and controversial, and fans either loved him or hated him. He finally picked Nikki Ferrell, but the couple's relationship was troubled until the bitter end. Juan Pablo and Nikki appeared on VH1's Couples Therapy, in which their main issue was JP's refusal to tell Nikki he loved her.

Andi Dorfman
Getty | Dave Kotinsky

Andi Dorfman

Andi appeared on Juan Pablo's season, but quickly became fed up with his shenanigans. After spending one camera-free night in the fantasy suite, Andi eliminated herself from the show. Andi went on to be the tenth Bachelorette and accepted Josh Murray's proposal. The couple ended their engagement later, and Andi wrote a scathing tell-all book, It's Not Okay, that dishes on all the juicy behind-the-scenes moments.

Chris Soules
ABC

Chris Soules

The farmer-turned-hunk made his Midwestern way into our hearts as a favorite on Andi's season, and then as the 19th Bachelor. Although he came in third, America was smitten with his humble, aw-shucks attitude and traditional values. Chris picked Whitney Bischoff, probably because of her willingness to move to his Iowa farm and be the farmer's wife, but she didn't make it long. The couple claims to maintain a friendship still, and Chris says they "talk often."

Kaitlyn Bristowe
Getty | Tommaso Boddi

Kaitlyn Bristowe

Kaitlyn came in second in Chris's season, but audiences loved her for humor and firecracker personality. Kaitlyn took a lot of criticism during her stint as the 11th Bachelorette, mostly because she was so physically and emotionally open with her suitors. Kaitlyn chose Shawn Booth in the end, but audiences had already figured it out, thanks to a Snapchat slip-up.

Ben Higgins
ABC

Ben Higgins

Ben Higgins is the lovable puppy of the Bachelor universe. I'm pretty sure Kaitlyn got hate mail when she rejected him. American women have never swooned so hard over a man confessing he felt "unlovable." In the end, he picked Lauren Bushnell, freeing up JoJo for her own stint on the show.

Joelle "JoJo" Fletcher
ABC

Joelle "JoJo" Fletcher

Our current Bachelorette didn't stay love-starved for too long. Even though Ben gave her the mother of all mixed signals, she's back in action the 12th season. Here's hoping JoJo learned from Ben's mistake, and will keep the "I love yous" to the bare minimum.