25 Thrillers on Netflix That Will Have You Sleeping With the Lights On

Creep stars Mark Duplass and Patrick Bice, and boy is it creepy. Duplass plays Josef, a loner whose need for companionship prompts him to post a Craigslist ad seeking a filmmaker to chronicle his life. When Aaron replies to the ad, he has no idea that Josef might be a killer. You'll want to sleep with the light on.

Watch it now.