16 Underrated Horror Movies on Netflix That Will Leave You Sleeping With the Light On

Anya Taylor-Joy plays Thomasin stars in this horror flick as a young woman who witnesses the disappearance of her youngest brother in 1630 New England and — as a result — is accused of witchcraft. Taylor-Joy plays Thomasin with such conviction that you actually believe she's trapped in a 17th-century waking nightmare, though her frightfully good performance is only matched by the demonic humanoid goat, Black Phillip.

Watch The Witch on Netflix.