For years, Allie thinks her first love, Noah, had abandoned her since her mother secretly confiscates all of the love letters he'd written to her. She finally confronts him during their rainy reunion years later ("Why didn't you write me? Why? It wasn't over for me"), which ends in the kiss to end all kisses. Our love for this scene wasn't over when we first saw it back in 2004, and it STILL isn't over now.