Yes, You Can Have a Sophisticated Elmo Party — See How Martha Stewart Did It!

Sticking to Alexis's desire to keep the kids' food healthy, she "made the Elmo gelatins using organic apple, cranberry, blueberry, apricot, and coconut juices," Martha shared. "The morning of the party, she cut all the shapes from slabs of jelly she had made in large baking sheets and assembled the faces."

At each child's seat was a printable Elmo placemat and printable box of Elmo crayons to keep little hands busy. "The boxes themselves were clip art, folded and taped into shape," Martha said.

Photo by Mimi Ritzen Crawford courtesy of Martha Stewart Living, copyright © 2014