The Best Old Navy Loafers to Wear on Repeat This Fall

Published on 8/18/2023 at 8:50 PM

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

You can never go wrong investing in a good pair of loafers. While some footwear trends come and go, they remain a shoe style that can withstand the test of time — and adapt to the ebbs and flows of your wardrobe. Though we're not discouraging you from investing in a designer pair, one of our go-to places to shop for them is Old Navy. The retailer carries multiple iterations of the footwear favorite, ranging from iconic penny loafers to modern Mary Jane hybrids, and they're all under $50.

Whether you're looking for a professional-looking pair to wear to the office or a modern take on the classic style, Old Navy has you covered. Ahead, we curated a list of our favorites to make things easy for you. The lineup includes an editor-loved style praised for their comfortable footbed and trendy, lug-sole heel, along with plenty more options straight from the brand's new-arrivals section. Keep scrolling for a look at our top 10 favorites, and find out what makes each one different.

Best Chunky Loafers

Old Navy Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes ($40)

These loafers star a shiny faux-leather upper and a comfy, cushioned footbed. Our editor put them to the test last year and fell in love with them; read her review of the Old Navy Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes for more.

Editor Quote: "The footbed is made of a cushioned woven twill that I was able to wear for the full day without desperately craving to take them off — as is the case with many of my shoes." — Marisa Petrarca, contributing editor, Commerce

Old Navy Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes

From

$40

Best Loafers With a Buckle

Old Navy Faux-Leather Chunky Heel Loafer Shoes ($40)

If you're looking for a style with hardware, consider these. The croc-embossed design exudes an elevated aesthetic without the hefty price tag.

Old Navy Faux-Leather Chunky Heel Loafer Shoes

From

$40

Best Faux-Suede Loafers

Old Navy Faux-Suede City Loafer Shoes ($30)

These faux-suede loafers will pair well with everything in your closet. They're brand-new, so they haven't garnered a ton of reviews just yet, but one shopper who rated them five stars described them as "comfortable and practical for a quarter of the price of any other equivalent!"

Old Navy Faux-Suede City Loafer Shoes

From

$30

Best Penny Loafers

Old Navy Faux-Leather Penny Loafer Shoes ($35)

Hurry to grab these classic penny loafers while they're still available. They're a brand bestseller, praised for their comfort, lightweight construction, and versatility.

Old Navy Faux-Leather Penny Loafer Shoes

From

$35

Best Faux-Leather Loafer Mule Shoes

Old Navy Faux-Leather Loafer Mule Shoes ($35)

Looking for a loafer with an open back? Your search ends here. These boast a buckled-front, a square toe, and a cushioned footbed.

Old Navy Faux-Leather Loafer Mule Shoes

From

$35

Best Croc-Embossed Loafer Mule Shoes

Old Navy Faux-Leather Loafer Mule Shoes ($35)

Love the mules in the last slide but prefer a bit more texture? This brown croc-embossed version will do the trick.

Old Navy Faux-Leather Loafer Mule Shoes

From

$35

Best Faux-Leather Loafers

Old Navy Faux-Leather City Loafer Shoes ($30)

These versatile loafers are a bit sleeker than classic penny loafers, thanks to their understated design. They come in cognac brown, croc-embossed brown, and black.

Old Navy Faux-Leather City Loafer Shoes

From

$30

Best Mary Jane Loafers

Old Navy Faux Leather Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes ($40)

These shoes are a unique fusion of Mary Janes and loafers with their rugged lug sole, chunky heel, and buckle strap. They come in black and brown.

Old Navy Faux Leather Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes

From

$40