Skip Nav
Most Stuf Oreos Are Here, and We Can't Even Fully Articulate How Massive They Are
Whole Foods
23 Whole Foods Staples For Busy People
Reese's Bouquets 2019
Valentine's Day
Walmart Is Selling a Reese's Bouquet, So I Know What I Want For Valentine's Day
Food News
Peeps Cereal Has Arrived at Target, and Yep, It Makes Your Milk Taste Like Marshmallows!
Original Recipes
The Only Instant Pot Chicken Noodle Soup Recipe You'll Ever Need

Bagel Grilled Cheese

The Grilled Cheese You Haven't Tried but Need To

Leftover grilled cheese is like leftover french fries — rarely something worth writing home about, except when it's in the form of an everything bagel grilled cheese from Sadelle's. While it's not something I would typically order to-go — something about room-temperature melted cheese doesn't usually do it for me — I'm very, very glad that my boyfriend surprised me with this superb spin on the classic grilled cheese after having lunch at the Manhattan restaurant. Even in its somewhat-compromised state, it was so good that I knew one bite in that it was something I'd have to re-create myself and share with you here.

It goes without saying, but this sandwich is even better piping-hot from the skillet, a perfect way to show yourself or someone near and dear to you some love. You could go classic and pair it with tomato soup, or do as Sadelle's does and serve it with a side of coleslaw. I prefer to pair it with cornichons as they're even more acidic and cut through the richness of the melted cheese. Also, do note that if you're not into everything bagels, other gritty bagels like sesame, onion, poppyseed, or garlic work well — the crunchy seeds help hold the cheese in place and provide textural contrast — but everything bagels are Sadelle's and my go-to.

Everything Bagel Grilled Cheese

Inspired by Sadelle's


For best results, use a textured bagel like an everything, poppyseed, onion, or sesame seed bagel, as it helps the cheese to stay in place as it melts and it adds textural and flavor contrast.

Bagel Grilled Cheese


  1. 1 everything bagel, sliced in half
  2. 1 tablespoon mayonnaise
  3. 1 1/2 ounces (1/2 cup) grated extra-sharp cheddar
  4. Cornichons for serving, optional


  1. Heat a nonstick skillet over medium-low heat.
  2. Spread the insides of the bagel with a thin layer of mayonnaise. Flip one bagel half so that the rounded side faces up, carefully layer with cheddar, gently pressing it onto the bagel, then arrange the other bagel half on top, rounded-side down.
  3. Carefully transfer the grilled cheese to the skillet and cook, covered with a lid for about 4-5 minutes, or until deep golden brown; carefully flip and cook for 3-4 more minutes, or until golden brown and the cheese is melted.
  4. Slice in half and serve with cornichons, if desired.

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Nicole Perry
From Our Partners
Spiked Hot Chocolate Recipes
Instant Pot Prime Rib Recipe
Leftover Mashed Potatoes Recipe Ideas
Instant Pot Chicken Noodle Soup Recipe
How to Save Calories on Your Sandwich
Zucchini Toast Recipe
Easy Healthy Dinner Recipes
Are Uncrustables Ravioli?
How to Make Healthy Sandwiches
Pioneer Woman's Tomato Soup Recipe
Easy Chicken Soup in an Instant Pot
Ree Drummond Casserole Recipes
From Our Partners
Latest Recipes, Menus, Food & Wine
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds