Skip Nav

Peeps Mystery Flavors 2016

Peeps Released Some Superweird Mystery Flavors For Easter

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photograhy / Erin Cullum

Once again, Peeps has come out with some intriguing mystery flavors ahead of Easter. There are three different packages of all-white Peeps chicks, and our office had some fun conductig a taste test and providing our best guesses. The flavors will be released before Easter (stay tuned!), but take a look at what you might expect based on everyone's opinions . . . we're a little scared about what number two might be.

Mystery Flavor #1

Most Popular Guesses:

  1. Chocolate
  2. Hot chocolate
  3. The marshmallow packets in hot chocolate (we're clearly onto something)

Actual flavor: Chocolate milk


Mystery Flavor #2

Most Popular Guesses:

  1. Butter
  2. Corn on the cob
  3. Buttered popcorn, like the Jelly Belly

Actual flavor: Buttered popcorn


Image Source: POPSUGAR Photograhy / Anna Roberts

Mystery Flavor #3

Most Popular Guesses:

  1. Fruit punch
  2. Berry
  3. Cherry
  4. Sour cherry

Actual flavor: Sour cherry


Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Erin Cullum
Latest Recipes, Menus, Food & Wine