Piña Colada Oreo Thins
We're glad the Piña Colada flavor ended up being an Oreo Thin, because the filling is the most intense out of the three. Very pineapple- and coconut-forward, this creme filling does taste slightly artificial, but if you're all about a fruity blended beverage, you'll probably love them.
"These would have been weird with a chocolate cookie, but the golden Oreo definitely complements the pineapple flavor," said one taster. Several people noted these are not their top choice, but at the end of the day, you've gotta give Oreo props for continuing to crank out the strangely wonderful flavor ideas.