Craving Something Sweet? These 31 Halloween Cookie Recipes Are Drop-Dead Delicious

You don't need to be obsessed with everything pumpkin spice to fall hard for these pumpkin-butter-filled thumbprint cookies, though a love for the cozy fall flavor doesn't hurt. Gently spiced, these festive sweets have a texture somewhere in between a cut-out sugar cookie and shortbread. In other words, they're a little bit tender, a little bit chewy, and butter rich.

Get the recipe: pumpkin pie thumbprint cookies