We Tested 15 Cozy Candles That Will Pumpkin Spice Up Your Home

Candlefish No. 46 ($22 for 11-ounce jar) with notes of fresh pumpkin, nutmeg, and anise.

• "This was my favorite and it smells like Charleston."
• "It's a little like what I'd expect a haunted mansion to smell like, but in a good way."
• "Fave! It smells like heaven . . . and Fall, of course."
• "Smells like cinnamon and Fall leaves. A bit sweet for my taste, but I like it!"