If You Only Buy 1 Yankee Candle Halloween Scent This Year, Make Sure It's This One

Yankee Candle "Haunted Hollow" ($20) with notes of pine woods and sweet incense.

We gave it:

Editors said:

• "Didn't think I would like it, but I do. Smells burnt, but in a good way."
• "Smokey but not too sweet. Like a burnt marshmallow."
• "For the seasonal aspect, I like that it smells like a fireplace, but I'm not sure if I'd actually burn this one."
• "Smokey, warm, and subtly sweet — I dig. Can I also just say that I appreciate the packaging?"
• "I prefer a straight-up firewood candle."