11 of the Best Comebacks For Common Pro-Trump Arguments

Many of us are approaching the remaining holiday gatherings this year with a sense of trepidation. Since the issues surrounding Donald Trump's campaign are, in many ways, personal rather than political, this election has driven a wedge not just between political parties, but also between families, friends, and loved ones.

Whether you're facing Trump's personal firing squad or a table filled with like-minded individuals this holiday season, you're (unfortunately) likely to encounter some inaccurate facts being thrown around (see: Facebook's fake news debacle).

To ensure that these conversations are educational, accurate, and based in truth, we've put together the following guide to handling and rebutting claims and arguments that tend to be popular amongst Trump-voting — and often well-meaning — family and friends.

01
"He'll have the sense to build a cabinet of trustworthy Republicans."
Getty | Drew Angerer

"He'll have the sense to build a cabinet of trustworthy Republicans."

How to respond: His appointments have thus far largely proved otherwise, as he has stacked his cabinet with some folks who have a history of racism and xenophobia. No matter your party lines, it's clear that many of Trump's choices hold disturbing beliefs. Here are a few of the individuals he has nominated:

  • Stephen Bannon is Trump's right-hand man, his pick for chief strategist, and was the CEO of Trump's presidential campaign. He is a leader of the white supremacist "alt-right" movement, and used to run the far-right "news" website (air quotes encouraged) Breitbart, known to perpetuate anti-minority and antiwomen sentiments. Bannon has consistently made troubling comments against women and minorities, among other marginalized groups.
  • Jeff Sessions has been appointed by Trump as attorney general. Sessions is a Republican Alabama senator whose federal judgeship nomination in 1986 was denied due to troubling racist comments; he is also a climate change skeptic and opponent of both legal and illegal immigration programs.
  • Betsy DeVos has been picked by Trump to be secretary of education. She is an ardent opponent of the American public school system, and supports school vouchers (a means of putting public funding toward private schools), charter schools, and homeschooling while opposing Common Core.
02
"He's a businessman."
Getty | AFP

"He's a businessman."

How to respond: Just because Trump is rich does not mean that he is a successful, ethical, or respectable businessman — he recently settled a $25 million fraud lawsuit surrounding his Trump University. Trump has also still not released his tax returns, and the New York Times reported that it's possible Trump has evaded paying taxes for almost 20 years.

There is also ample evidence that Trump's business acumen is less-than-stellar. In fact, his track record includes inflating his net worth by more than $2.7 billion, borrowing $7.5 million from his father to pay back Chase for a defaulted loan, and failing to turn a profit on a series of ill-advised business ventures in sectors he knew nothing about. There is extensive documentation that he has botched multiple multimillion-dollar deals, lived off his father, and cheated hardworking people over the course of his career.

03
"There's nothing to be afraid of."
Getty | Drew Angerer

"There's nothing to be afraid of."

How to respond: Sure, Trump is unlikely to show up at your doorstep, mosque, or grocery store and harass you — but his reach is wide, and even the bluest of states are not free from hate crimes sparked by a president-elect who has given white supremacists (and anyone with a hateful streak) permission to reveal themselves.

Following Trump's election, the Southern Poverty Law Center tracked almost 900 reports of harassment and intimidation in the 10 days following Nov. 8. Many of these hate crimes and related incidents have been targeted toward some of the groups most condemned by Trump's rhetoric and policies, including women, Muslims, Mexican-Americans, immigrants, and the LGBTQ community.

The number of reports in the days after Trump's win spiked by six percent, indicating a connection to Trump's win. Despite taking the time to condemn the casts of Hamilton and SNL, Trump's only public comment on these events came during his 60 Minutes interview, when he told perpetrators to "stop it."

We can also look to his 100-day plan as proof that people have reason to be afraid — his ambitious wish list of goals includes imposing term limits, constructing a border wall and forcing Mexico to reimburse the US for costs, rolling back aspects of the Affordable Care Act, renegotiating NAFTA, withdrawing from the Trans-Pacific Partnership, lifting blocks on energy infrastructure projects (like the Keystone Pipeline), and canceling federal funding to so-called sanctuary cities.

Trump's plans would be severely damaging and dangerous to marginalized Americans as well as the country as a whole. While defense and transportation sectors could reap some benefits of a Trump presidency, it's predicted that Trump's plans could severely damage foreign trade relations, rob at least 20 million people of their health insurance, and widen the gap between America's richest and poorest citizens.

04
"It was just locker room talk."
Getty | George Pimentel

"It was just locker room talk."

(In regards to the resurfaced 2005 video in which Trump says he grabs women "by the p*ssy.")

How to respond: This deeply disturbing language has lasting effects. Writing his comments off as "locker room talk" illustrates what Psychology Today calls "a basic misunderstanding about the power of words." Indeed, "the ways in which we speak 'prime' us to think in certain ways, and we don't even notice it." And as the Huffington Post points out, words affect behavioral changes.

Even if you do excuse Trump's words, they take on a significantly deeper meaning when considered alongside the long line of women who have come forward to accuse him of sexual assault and/or misconduct. Accusations range from Trump kissing women without their consent to walking in on women as they changed, groping a woman at a nightclub, and raping more than one woman.

05
"Mike Pence will actually be running the show."
Getty | Aaron P. Bernstein

"Mike Pence will actually be running the show."

How to respond: Many believe that, due to Trump's inexperience and disinterest in matters such as security briefings, Vice President Mike Pence may be the one running the show. Though some feel assured by Pence's political experience, having the VP-elect take the reigns could be even more dangerous than Trump himself — though less bombastic and overly offensive on a day-to-day basis, Pence has painfully backwards views on social issues.

Former Indiana governor Pence is an Evangelical Christian with a long history of anti-LGBTQ policies, like advocating for "pray the gay away" conversion therapy, and pro-religious freedom legislation. He has also supported the Tea Party movement and antiabortion laws like requiring women to have a burial or cremation service for their fetus after getting an abortion or miscarrying.

06
"He united the people."
Getty | Scott Olson

"He united the people."

How to respond: But did he? Trump may have won 306 electoral votes compared to Hillary Clinton's 232, but she currently holds more than 2.5 million more votes than the president-elect. Thus, Trump did not "unite the people" — in fact, this election has caused a serious divide amongst Americans that's unlikely to be remedied for years to come.

Trump ran his campaign based on a platform of capitalizing on a subconscious (or, for the white supremacist movement, very conscious) fear of the "other," represented by various marginalized groups who were attacked over the course of his campaign. Despite being part of the one percent, Trump has continuously played to the average white American, those most susceptible to rhetoric against immigrants, the LGBTQ community, women, refugees, and anyone else that falls into this category of "other." When you run a campaign based on pitting one group of Americans against many others, you're doing the opposite of uniting people.

07
"But the emails."
Getty | Mark Makela

"But the emails."

How to respond: Yes, Clinton messed up by using a private email server. However, she has been cleared not once, but twice by the FBI — despite what seems to be director James Comey's own apparent political investment in the matter. To call Clinton a criminal because of charges relating to an email server mix-up that have never even been filed while supporting a candidate who recently settled a $25 lawsuit for duping millions of vulnerable Americans, still hasn't released his tax returns, and was set to go on trial for raping a 13-year-old girl is, simply, supporting a narrative that speaks to pre-established prejudices and beliefs.

There's yet another layer of hypocrisy in this debate — while Trump has labeled Clinton "corrupt" and condemned her for the email server scandal, he is reportedly considering resigned CIA Director David Petraeus for the position of secretary of state. In 2015, Petraeus pled guilty to charges of sharing confidential information with his lover and biographer. He is currently on probation for these crimes.

08
"People don't hate Hillary Clinton because she's a woman, they hate her for all those other reasons."
Getty | Justin Sullivan

"People don't hate Hillary Clinton because she's a woman, they hate her for all those other reasons."

How to respond: Just because all Trump voters didn't actively think, "I'm going to vote for the man because I hate women" (though some likely did), it doesn't mean that the perception of Clinton wasn't significantly affected by her gender. As Newsweek noted after the election"men and women really did choose a presidential candidate this year based on their attitudes about what was acceptable behavior towards women." Indeed, the election saw a measured correlation between hostile attitudes toward women and support for Trump.

Clinton was a prime example of the issues recounted in Sheryl Sandberg's seminal Lean In, where she explores the ways in which women are expected to be warm, friendly, and charismatic — and are penalized and criticized when they're not.

While strong traits in males are generally considered favorable for a leader, strong women are often characterized as "b*tchy" (a favorite of Trump supporters) or "cold" — thus, if you dislike Clinton because she's cold, b*tchy, annoying, or flat-out unlikeable, it's important to reexamine the root of this characterization.

09
"She's being a sore loser by supporting a recount."
Getty | Justin Sullivan

"She's being a sore loser by supporting a recount."

How to respond: Though Clinton's campaign has now agreed to assist with Jill Stein's recount efforts, they have made it clear that Clinton is not responsible for or even very hopeful about them.

Clinton's campaign was reportedly reluctant to pursue this option, and did not join efforts even after leading computer scientists and voters around the country urged the Clinton campaign to call for a recount. It was only after Stein filed for a recount in Wisconsin that the Clinton campaign finally spoke up — and though they've confirmed that they will assist with and support recount efforts, they have also made it clear that they did not want, push for, or seek out a recount.

Additionally, Clinton counsel Marc Elias wrote that her camp does not believe there is "evidence of manipulation of results," but is participating because of the "obligation to the more than 64 million Americans who cast ballots for Hillary Clinton."

10
"Why should people get to come into the US for free when my friends had to jump through hoops to legally bring their wives?"
Getty | John Moore

"Why should people get to come into the US for free when my friends had to jump through hoops to legally bring their wives?"

(OK, this is a real one I overheard while at the airport recently, but simplified it's: "It's not fair that illegal immigrants get rewarded for doing it the wrong way.")

How to respond: This comment is largely based on misconceptions about the paths of legal immigration and the plight of the immigrants who choose to try to get in illegally. Many people are not immigrating illegally because they want to break the law — they are doing so because they truly believe it is their only option.

This is true for a variety of reasons. First, there are only three main routes for migrating legally to the US: employment, family reunification, or humanitarian protection. Each of these routes is subject to limits, caps, strict guidelines, and burdens of proof, and — perhaps most dangerous for those seeking safety — long waits. Thus, even if you are eligible for legal immigration (which many people are not), the red tape makes the chances of getting in legally extremely low.

Additionally, many are running from oppressive governments or dangerous gangs and violence, all of which incite a sense of urgency that the current legal immigration systems cannot accommodate. Beyond these forces, the US itself has played a role in the circumstances that encourage illegal immigration, according to the Huffington Post, "by overthrowing democratically elected governments" and "pushing trade policies that undermine Latin American industries."

Undocumented immigrants are also risking their lives — between 1998 and 2014, there have been more than 6,000 deaths amongst people trying to cross the southwest border into the US in a desperate attempt to secure a brighter future. It's also important to note that those who do make it into America alive do not enjoy the same benefits of legal immigrants; instead, those who immigrate illegally face low-paying jobs, manual labor, no government benefits, and significant discrimination — all without any promise of future payoff.

11
"Muslims are a danger to the US."
Getty | David McNew

"Muslims are a danger to the US."

How to respond: Trump's war against Muslims is rooted in fear of the "other," not in the truth. In fact, Muslims only make up around one percent of the US population, do not support ISIS or their violent methods, and have brought more Muslim-American terrorism suspects to the attention of law enforcement since 9/11 than the US government's own efforts.

Unfortunately, perceptions about Muslim-Americans often do not reflect this reality — as is painfully evident by Trump's critiques of slain US Army Captain Humayun Khan's Gold Star parents; in Trump's eyes (and those of many other fearful Americans), the threat of religious and cultural "otherness" overrides the significance of serving (and giving your life for) our country.

This approach mimics Trump's campaign against other marginalized groups — just as he exploited middle America's frustrations with Mexican immigrants, he exploited America's fear of ISIS and terrorism to condemn innocent individuals coming to our country for freedom. Under his presidency, he'll likely find even more ways to take vulnerable groups seeking opportunity in the US and manipulate the American people into seeing them as the enemy.