If you have a total obsession with NYX Cosmetics, you're not alone. This cruelty-free brand has garnered quite the following since it was founded in 1999. From its wide range of eye shadows and never-ending lip collections, we're continuously hooked. If you can't decide which product to get, we made it easy and sorted through Amazon's in-depth customer reviews. Whether it's blush or lip liner you seek, check out these top-rated products, and get ready to find your next love.