Skip Nav

I Tried Milk Makeup's Color Chalk Eyeshadow Sticks | Review

I Tried Milk Makeup's Color Chalk Eyeshadow Sticks, and the Shimmer Is Unreal

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Jessica Harrington
Let's be real: I'm not wearing much eyeshadow these days. My eye makeup consists of mascara, maybe a little liner, and occasionally, when I'm feeling fancy, I blend some of my bronzer onto my eyelids and call it a day. Prepandemic, I used to blend multiple different eyeshadow shades together on my lids to create a full smoky, sometimes shimmery, look, but I haven't cracked open any of my palettes in over a year. The only way I'm going to apply eyeshadow at home is if it's a quick-and-easy, swipe-and-go type of product, which is how I got into the Milk Makeup Color Chalk.

The Milk Makeup Color Chalks ($18) are individually wrapped sticks of pigment that come in 14 shades, ranging from neutrals to brights. They're packaged in a reusable storage tube with a paper wrapper that you peel off as you go. The fun format reminds me of drawing with sidewalk chalk as a kid, except this formula is sparkly and doesn't feel dry like the chalk of my childhood. The eyeshadow is unlike any makeup product I've seen before.

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Jessica Harrington

I applied the Color Chalk in two different ways: first, by using the stick directly on my eyelid and then blending the pigment with a brush; and second, by using my fingertip to pick up pigment from the applicator and then rubbing that onto my eyelid. I found both methods worked great but gave very different finishes. Using the stick directly on my eyelid gave a strong color payoff, while blending it using my fingertip made for a softer, diffused look.

Due to the chalky, glittery consistency, the formula can be a little clumpy when you first apply it, but it's nothing a little blending can't fix. The pigments are incredibly soft and shimmery, and are perfect for a quick eyeshadow look, whether you're on the go or just short on time.

In the photo above, I'm wearing the shade Kickball, a golden bronze hue.

Image Source: Courtesy of Milk Makeup

Milk Makeup Color Chalks
Milk Makeup Color Chalks
Buy Now
Latest Beauty