10 Easy, Cool-Looking Costumes You Can Make With Eyeliner

This makeup palette is part rock star, part pirate. You'll need two separate eyeliner products to get Jack's dusty, smudged eye-makeup look. Use a pencil to create the dark circles underneath the eye and around the top lids. Then, take a fine-tip liquid liner to draw in each hair of the mustache and beard.

"If you want a 5 o'clock shadow, use your black pencil as well as your favorite brown eyeliner," Bartlett said. "Rub that on the back of your hand, and use a makeup brush with a stiff fiber to pick up the product. To apply, use a stippling motion, which creates texture on the face."