15 Fall Must-Have Beauty Buys That Editors Love This September

I believe that you have to ease yourself into Fall makeup after the fresh-faced beauty of Summer — otherwise, you and your skin will feel smothered. I'm getting back into the eye shadow groove with this impossibly beautiful Lilah B. palette ($58). The powders are soft, creamy, and featherlight with a buildable formula, so I can start with a minimal application at the beginning of the month and work my way to a smoky eye by October. Plus, the heavy stone-inspired packaging feels and looks so fabulous, it's taken up permanent residence as a paperweight on my desk.

—EO