These Are the Beauty Gifts Editors Are Asking For This Holiday Season

If you haven't tried Benefit's cult They're Real Mascara, then there is no better time to grab this lengthening essential. The bottle got a special "outfit" for the holidays that entails a Swarovski crystal-studded cap ($26). I've been a fan of this wand for years because of the glossy black finish and its ability to actually make me look like I'm wearing falsies.

—LL