Will You Accept This Contouring Brush? 6 Makeup Secrets From the Bachelor Girls

Moldavon suggests Ashunta Sheriff Perfect Blend Foundation ($40), which has both a light and dark side to each stick.

"You don't have to search for highlight or lowlight," she explained. "It's a pretty good place to start." She also loves Tarte's Shape Tape Concealer ($24) and Charlotte Tilbury's Filmstar Bronze & Glow Contour Palette ($68), the latter of which because it's subtle and "doesn't leave a giant stripe on the face."

However, these products work best on certain skin types. "For Lauren, because she's probably the fairest of them all, I use the Charlotte Tilbury," she noted. "On Sarah . . . Tarte's Shape Tape in light medium."