The All-Star Eye Makeup Removers You Need in Your Beauty Lineup

If you've ever tried to get Benefit's They're Real Mascara off of your lashes, you know it's no easy feat (yet a struggle well worth enduring for a long, voluminous flutter). Leave it to a remover that shares the same name to dissolve all that dark, inky goodness without so much as a tug. The cream-based formula ($12, originally $18) gently lifts away waterproof everything, leaving eyes feeling hydrated instead of stripped of all moisture.