What Fenty Beauty's New Holiday Lipsticks Actually Look Like on 4 Women

The Shade: Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Supermoon (sparkling peach), $19

The Review: "This is my first time trying a Fenty product (I know, I'm late!) and after putting Starlit on my lips, I'm a fan. I wasn't wearing any makeup on this day, not even ChapStick, and the lipstick looked completely natural on my face. It glided seamlessly across my lips and didn't leave weird smudge marks. The color looks peachy pink in the tube, but upon application, it shimmers in the light. The lipstick's a great option for everyday wear if you want a pop of color." — Marina Liao, assistant fashion editor