What Fenty Beauty's New Holiday Lipsticks Actually Look Like on 4 Women

The Shade: Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Sci-Fly (glimmering garnet), $19

The Review: "This lipstick is superversatile because it appears like a dark berry color in some lights but in others, it looks like a dark wine color. It's full of glitter, but you don't feel it on the lips one bit. It's the perfect lip to rock from day to night." — Celia Fernandez, assistant POPSUGAR Latina editor