Beauty Experts Reveal Exactly How They Would Spend $25 at Target

"Perhaps my favorite beauty bargain ever is L'Oréal's Voluminous Mascara ($6). I've used this formula for decades because it creates the most beautiful, full lashes. There are a variety of versions now available. I tend to favor the Carbon Black, though any of the formulas in the range could stand up to a luxury mascara at a fraction of the price." — Rodriguez