The Gross, Guilty Pleasure Madelaine Petsch Shares With Millions Of People

"My boyfriend [Travis Mills] is pretty used to seeing me with weird stuff on my face," Petsch laughed. "He's very used to my obsession with skin care, so it's not a new thing to him. Most men don't know how to take care of their blackheads, and one of my favorite things on the planet is to put my Bioré Witch Hazel Ulta Deep Cleansing Pore Strips ($7) on him. It's the best, because then you get to look at all the good juice afterward. Oh god, I'm disgusting."