Popsugar Beauty Nostalgia The Best Nostalgic Beauty Gifts 16 Nostalgic Gifts That Will Make Any Beauty-Lover Smile October 12, 2020 by India Yaffe View On One Page Photo 2 of 17 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 2 MAC Lip Pencil The MAC Lip Pencil ($18) was a staple in everyone's makeup bag, and still is today. Scoring the shade Spice was like winning the lottery. MAC Lip Pencil $18 from nordstrom.com Buy Now Previous Next Start Slideshow NostalgiaBeauty ShoppingGift GuideBeauty GiftsGiftsShopping