Every Product Used to Create Kate and Jeanette's '90s Beauty Looks in Cruel Summer

The slight frizziness of Jeanette's hair and modest makeup in '93 make her second phase in '94 with pin-straight hair all the more impactful. "She wanted to be that beautiful, popular, blond girl in school," Kirkpatrick said. Kate's disappearance felt like the perfect time to do just that.

"When she's the hot girl, Jeanette's color palette was lots of browns — these were the colors that were popular back then," Trujillo said. She used brown lipstick and brown eyeshadow to establish Jeanette's look, and contoured her face to fake the progression of age.