Our Editors Buy These 12 Beauty Products Over and Over Again

"I was never a lip liner fan until I tried the Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat Lip Liner ($22) in Pillowtalk. It is incredible; the pinky neutral hue looks good on pretty much everyone, and it gives me the perfect shape to my lips. The formula is creamy and easy to blend, and I'll pair it with the Charlotte Tilbury Superstar Lips ($34) in Pillowtalk for a creamy, shiny finish. It's my go-to lip color, and pretty much the only one I use." — India Yaffe, associate editor, Commerce