2025 Popsugar Beauty Awards: 61 Winners, Handpicked by Our Editors

Pat McGrath Labs Dramatique Mega Lip Pencil ($29)

Consider this the love child of a precision lip liner and a creamy, pigmented lipstick. The result? A bold, dramatic lip color that glides on like butter, stays vibrant, and looks like it took pro-level effort (spoiler alert: it didn't). Whether you're going for Taylor Swift's signature "red lip, classic thing" or a blurred, effortlessly French girl vibe, this pencil delivers. With a creamy, lightweight formula and 11 swoon-worthy shades (yes, including that iconic Elson red), it's versatile enough to handle everything from coffee runs to red-carpet-worthy glam. Swipe it on, and watch the compliments roll in.