2025 Popsugar Beauty Awards: 61 Winners, Handpicked by Our Editors

Glossier Eyeshadow Sticks ($22)

If you haven't already met, let us introduce you to the unsung hero of eyeshadows: Glossier Eyeshadow Sticks. These creamy, blendable bad boys will have you wondering why you didn't get on the shadow stick train sooner. The formula is a dream, gliding onto your eyelids like silk, and the payoff is an instant pop of color with no mess. These sticks are the perfect balance of pigmented and subtle, giving you a natural glow or a bold pop, depending on your vibe. Bonus points for being travel-friendly because you know your makeup bag needs that kind of versatility. It's basically foolproof — swipe it on, blend it out, and boom: eyes that sparkle with barely any effort.